Wednesday, January 10, 2007

A Couple of Blog Conversations

Often, blogging is a conversation that bounces from blog to blog, or develops into long comment threads. Here are a couple recent integrobuddhoblog conversations you all may relish by reading or by jumping in on by adding your comments to a post on the topic, or by posting on the matter in your own blog, if you have one. And if you don’t have a blog, start one. The easiest way to start one? Probably at Blogger.com .


Why Meditate?

Buzz started on meditation when Jeff Wilson wrote on Dec 26, in Tricycle Blog –Jeff Wilson, a tangential statement of fact in a rambling post comparing Japan and America, that “meditation is quite uncommon in Japanese Zen.”

The first comment to the post, written by Pat Montague, asked about the statement, “How does this square with the enormous emphasis placed on meditation in Shunryu Suzuki's “Zen Mind, Beginner's Mind”? [Suzuki, a patriarch of Zen in America, started the San Francisco Zen Center, which focused on meditation, in the early 60s and he and the center were quickly sensations during the beatnik era carrying over to the hippie era. Zen Mind, Beginner’s Mind was first published in 1970 – a year before Suzuki died. The book continues to be popular.]

Jeff devoted a new, long post on Dec 30 – a journal-quality article, really – to Pat’s comment, titling it “Meditation: A Rare Practice.” Jeff demonstrated the truth of his assertion that meditation is rare in Japan, and in Asia, too. He also explained why meditation became central to Western Buddhists: because it quickly became what lay Buddhists were interested in and because it was the easiest thing for English-challenged teachers to give instruction in. Jeff summed things up with these words, “Obviously, this isn't meant as an attack on meditation, which I too value. But we should be aware that meditation is not a common Buddhist practice, including within Zen. Helpful to some, valued by many, but by no means common.”

In the comment threat to “Meditation: A Rare Practice,” the discussion broadened along these lines: The great opportunity that the Internet affords and the Buddhist literature that Westerners have generally allows for a wonderful foundation to study and practice our religion and to know how Buddhism is practiced elsewhere in the world.

Jeff’s post caught the eye of CJ of CJ’s Words who wrote in a Jan 9 post, starkly titled "Real Buddhists Don't Meditate," “I was quite pleased to read [about the rarity of meditation in Jeff’s post], as [I am] a lazy meditator. It strikes me that it really is a central theme in Western Buddhism and often the aspect that one will come across first and practise before having any inkling of ethics. Why are we so into this sitting still and navel gazing practice? Does it help us feel like we're being spiritual or does the daily discipline make us feel like we're being good Buddhists?”

CJ then quoted Wade from a Jan 2 post in his The Middle Way blog: “Meditation is not just sitting down on a zafu, or chanting...the Eightfold Path... is applied in all aspects of life, from talking to others, to breathing, to understanding things correctly.”

Jeff G. in his Barefoot Path took things from there on Jan 9, citing CJ's post and then writing in support of meditation. “We are creatures of habit and normal habit energy has us jumping from distraction to distraction. By practicing meditation we set the conditions to help us change our habit energy and allow our minds a little more spaciousness before reacting to external stimuli. This translates into our lives in real and concrete ways.”

Whither now, Integral?

Hokai in hokai’s blogue wrote unctuously of a post he read, “I thought and expected better of Paul Salamone.”

Paul had written a post titled “Integral: What Now?” in Paul’s Blog in the community of zaadz. Paul mused on what was now to become of I-I, Integral Institute, now that the wind had left its sails with staff layoffs [including himself] and the longterm health problems of Ken Wilber.

Paul proposed that people “continue to cultivate the intellectual curiosity which brought us to integral in the first place”, seek “a renewed commitment to personal development and practice” and “[refocus] on artistic and media-based [expression] OF an integral vision – of a life lived with greater freedom and fullness.” He also envisions a support community outside I-I for Integral ex-pats and other outsiders [or folks appalled by the cult they believe Wilberism has become] to buttress zaadz and Integral World. [Integral World is Frank Vissar’s website, chockablock with essays that analyse Integral issues. Many if not most of the some 750 essays in IW take Ken Wilber to task for perceived errors or inconsistancies in his writings. Last June, Wilber notoriously lashed out at Integral World and his critics, telling them to ‘suck my dick’ in a blogpost that was either a rant disguised as a test or a test disguised as a rant.]

In his post, Hokai was spitting venom, sarcastically dismissing the ex-pats as lazy and unskilled and lacking the dedication to move Wilber’s vision forward. He wrote, “Ken Wilber is desperately in need of competent staff, … people who don't see themselves as the ones who will take the integral vision further before they can attain the basic discipline of a five-year old.”

In what may be closely connected to all this is a post in ebuddha’s Integral Practice that delves into the mishaps of Andrew Cohen, Ken Wilber’s dialogue buddy who is now an authoritanian guru who has repeated abusive behaviour problems – including, perhaps, theft of $2 million from a troubled disciple. Even Cohen’s mother can’t stand him.

There are other personality-disordered characters associated with or at or near the top of the extended Wilber Empire exhibiting many similar authoritarian, abusive, greedy, narcissistic and needy traits. There is rot within bringing the whole world down. And what would be laughable if it weren't so depressing is that so many continue to think that Wilber and Cohen and Gafni and others are themselves at the cutting edge of enlightened human development, when obviously they can't walk the walk and we should be more earnest at questioning whether they can talk the talk.

Tuesday, January 09, 2007

Roundup for Jan 9, 2007

copyright, Danny Fisher

A central detail from a photograph in a post titled "India Post #23" by Danny Fisher in his same-name blog.

It's a beautiful day in the buddho­blogospheric neighborhood; A beautiful day for a blog-reading neighbor; Would you be mine? ... Could you be mine?...

But it may not be a beautiful day for long. Ajahn Punnadhammo in Bhikkhu’s Blog writes about the severe threat of climate change and gives us a Buddhist approach to meet the challenges. This is a must-read post, y’all; a planet saver. Writes the bhikkhu, “… Buddhism can make a real contribution. Buddhism teaches the virtue of santutthi, contentment with little.”

In his 23rd post from India, Danny Fisher presents more wonderful photographs in his blog, Danny Fisher. Be sure to click on Danny’s 18 thumbnails to enjoy the splendor of his photographs – the colors! the wonders! – in a size such that you feel you are there, with the chaplain in India. A central detail from one of his photos is at left.

John Craig of Craig Photography takes dog Kiani, coffee, but no camera on a nature hike. With text alone in an outstanding essay, John captures the beauty of a farmer’s field and a silent wood. A snippet: “Sitting on a non-moss covered log I see the white tail of a deer, then another tail and another tail. Deer heads start popping out of the low brush; I am resting in the herd’s nest.”

James of Genius of Insanity is excited that the middleground is finding both sides in the stem cell debate. Scientific research to the rescue! The latest, if you haven’t heard, is that new work investigating amniotic cells strongly suggests that they might reap powerful, curative benefits in mankind’s future – without use of destroyed embryos.

Ryan Oelke, of Integral Awakening and one of the podcasting Buddhist Geeks [qv], is kissing up to the Zero Boss [qv], maybe, which will possibly help his chances in this month’s “Blogging for Books” contest. Ryan’s entry is “Time Yoga,” which was originally posted in IA last April.

“Tonight...I douse myself in geekery, and light the match of...um...nerdiness.” So writes Bob Goodfriend in a post about three weeks ago about computer games, but mostly about BattleLore, the “big fantasy battle game,” that he had just received. Chicago Bob was begun on Dec 4, but is only now getting blasted into the buddhoblogosphere by the jet engines of Technorati. Bob’s post yesterday revealed his resolutions for the new year, which include keeping his weight down, reading and studying Buddhism, extending his leadership skills in SGI and to fight less with his wife and when they do quarrel for it to resolve itself positively. And, to be a great daddy to his daughter, Ren, born five days ago.

digitalzen of Digital Dharma wants us to know he packed up his electrons and moved to http://digital-dharma.net/. But the old address still works, too.

Renegade Buddha of the same-name blog has made a triumphant return to bloggery with twenty posts in just the last few days, after just a few posts all of last year – and those were in March. Recent posts include lots of great vids, a post on labels and praise for a quote by tinythinker of peaceful turmoil on Buddhist stereotypes, with commentary.

All for now, everyone. But I may add more stuff t'morrow.

Sunday, January 07, 2007

Roundup for Jan 7, 2007

Grand Canyon

A portion of a photograph in a post titled "Impermanence" by Dharmasattva in the blog Dharmasattva's Meditations.

There is pain and there is beauty in the buddhoblogosphere. Here, some wild samples, some good ones, posted on Jan 6, plucked fresh from the Internet meadow with the dew still clinging.

Dharmasattva, of Dharmasattva's Meditations, shows us that the Grand Canyon demonstrates the Buddhist principle of impermanence. “Even the earth under our feet is dynamic and ever-changing.” [See a portion of one of Dharmasattva's photographs, at left.]

Dee, the ordinary immortal of Urban Mystic, writes to recommend a book, Life is ForEver. The book makes the case that the mind and brain are not the same. The book is important since those that believe that death brings oblivion are getting their case heard in Britain, while those that believe and have evidence for immortality are not being heard.

Joe Perez of Until has quit his job because of health issues. His situation, which he describes at some length, seems very serious. He is interested in recommendations readers of his blog might have on how to use meditation to deal with chronic pain. Blogmandu readers: Any knowledge about this, thoughts or ideas you could share with Joe?

Moose, The Contemporary Taoist, has been absent without leave from his blogging duties, with just a couple posts in the last couple months, but he is happy to report that past pieces in his column, called “The Contemporary Taoist,” in LivingNow hardcopy magazine will soon be available online. Moose should know; he’s in charge, re-vamping the magazine’s online presence.

Howdy Seven, S’long Six. Justin Whitaker welcomes in the new year in American Buddhist Perspective and then is visited by the Ghost of Blogging Past who takes him on an extended texty tap dance down the garden trail of a year gone by. One pithy bit of wisdom plucked from last June: “In life, what is needed is less map and more compass.”

C4’s fav wine merchant, Joshua Zader of Mudita Journal, is keen on an audio CD called “True Meditation” by Adyashanti. After meditating for twenty minutes following listening to the first hour of the 3 ½ hr. CD, Joshua has been in a fairly “perpetual state of witness consciousness” since.

whiskey of whiskey river posts A Triangle. It’s like a haiku that Escher might write, you think?

A Triangle of Thought

Our memories mellow time
As wine mellows memories
as time mellows the wine
- Linda Delayen

TMCG of the same-name blog was jazzed seeing a rockumentary on the Pixies called loudQUIETloud. She writes that the Pixies wrote the soundtrack of her generation such that “not a moment of the movie went by that I didn't have some memory associated with a bass line, howling vocal, swirl-grinding guitar or kick-pedal pound.”

Paul, A Blue Eyed Buddhist, writes, in a post titled “I love America,” “Is this a great country, or what?” The cause of his glee: New Muslim congressman Keith Ellison has his picture taken being sworn in by Speaker Nancy Polosi, using a two-volume Koran that had belonged to Thomas Jefferson. The scene has Paul wondering if Jefferson might have had a copy of the Lotus Sutra that might be held in the Library of Congress, somewhere.

A couple Buddhist blogs posted yesterday or today regarding a 50 min. video that is free online - A BBC/Discovery Channel co-production, The Life of the Buddha, found at Marcello’s E-Dharma blog, originally posted in November. Word is getting out. TMCG says the E-Dharma link is great. Bill of Integral Options Cafe says the film is "a good quality production, worthy of watching."

That's all for today, y'all. Happy blogging and blog reading to everyone!

Saturday, December 30, 2006

Roundup for Dec 30, 2006

Nine Steppingstones

Detail from a photograph in a post titled "in memorium" by Michael of One foot in front of the other.

Whoa! It's been a while, but allow me to begin again and get a head start on my New Year's resolution. Here, at long last love: more juicy goodness from the thriving integralbuddhoblogosphere. All of the following is just some of what was wonderful yesterday:

Wonderful writing and photographs in F & X Kwan’s foot before foot: the photoblog make a visit to the couple’s blogspace delightful, even as their lives seem always to be a hard slog. Yesterday, there was rain.

Baghdad Burning, a blog reporting events from Iraq’s capital, had been down for quite a while, but it is back. Ajahn Punnadhammo tells us of a recent post in that famous blog with an entry in his Bhikkhu’s Blog, reporting from the safe, quiet wooded compound of Arrow River Forest Hermitage, west of Thunder Bay.

Cliff Jones of This is This manages a TV network or somesuch in Britain and was under the razor of an Arab barber when a call came in from the vid guy at work regarding what to air of Saddam’s execution. Cliff relates his dicey conversation on a cellphone in the busy-barber’s chair.

Whiskey of whiskey river quotes Fyodor Doestoevsky’s The Idiot. It begins, “You smile at the absurdity of your dream and feel at the same time that the tissue of those absurdities contains some thought …”

Michael of One foot in front of the other remembers a blog friend who died in a recent automobile accident in his touching post "in memorium." His post includes a photograph the woman admired of his, showing a country road in Japan.

Steroids of chess: George P. Dvorsky of Sentient Developments considers the future of competitive chess. Hidden devises that supply computer access, stimulants, and “genetically modified competitors” all pose a challenge to fairly contested events. George concludes, “…as the human species changes so too must our competitive activities. The rules of sport, whether these sports require mental or physical skill, will have to bend in the face of the biotech wind.”

James in his The Buddhist Blog posts a quote from Stephen Batchelor that concludes with this summative sentence, “The survival of Buddhism today is dependent on its continuing ability to adapt.” James finds the teaching valuable in his own life in remembering not to be judgmental of the path other Buddhists take dealing creatively with each of their unique life’s challenges.

Writes Mike of Unknowing Mind, “The new year is fast approaching, and what better time than [this] to take stock of your life, and dedicate just 10% of it to true daily practice. Allow the other 90% to continue living exactly as you do now.”

Bill of Integral Options CafĂ© has been keeping us abreast of ‘best of” lists that have been coming out in recent weeks. Yesterday, he found three more: Cinematical’s best ten films of 06; Ten wildlife conservation success stories in 06; and the 500 greatest albums of all time, according to Rolling Stone’s 60s-and-70s prejudice editors.

And finally, speaking of “best of”s, the nominations for the 2007 Blogisattva Awards, honoring excellence in Buddhist blogging during calendar year 2006, will be announced right here, in Blogmandu, in the middle of next month. There will be 50% more categories and 50% more nominees than last year [2006 nominees; 2006 winners], reflecting the growth in quantity, variety and quality of Buddhist blogs, bloggers and their posts. Yowza! Blog on and read on, y’all.

Monday, October 30, 2006

Roundup for Oct 30, 2006

copyright X. Kwan, 2006

© x kwan, 2006. Detail from picture Little Miss Perky by X. Kwan, posted in "Bushed" in the blog by F & X Kwan foot before foot: the photoblog.

Ooop. Blogmandu has been neglected! But today, alas, a new entry.

Here’s what’s new and spiffy in the integral- and buddhoblogospheres:

tinythinker in peaceful turmoil writes of some of his more serious attachments, how attachments can be intellectually described and then, very helpfully, pulls us up out of any intellectual tule fog with this visualization
Until you have started really seeing [your attachments], like strings on a puppet moving you about as conditions in your life appear to change, [intellectual depictions of what attachments are are inadequate]. And, of course, it's even harder to see that, in fact, there are no strings (yes, it is a bit reminiscent of the "no spoon" line from that Zennish motion picture). When one is/is in the realization, rather than anticipating it or acknowledging [it] after the fact, there is nothing to hinder or become hindered by.
George of Sentient Developments has been posting what he calls a “Buddha Break” every few days since the 17th, in “an effort to write more about Buddhist topics and tie it into the context of [his] blog.” In his fifth and latest “break,” George writes about a meditation class conducted by his yoga instructor that had elements that are contrary to the practice he’s accustomed to, based on the vipassana tradition. Writes George
Once the meditation started we focused on the breath – a practice that I’m very familiar with. But after a few minutes of that he had us move ‘beyond’ a focus on the breath to a focus on the pure mind. This I could not understand nor accomplish. In fact, the idea of zoning-out like this is anathema to my own notions as to why we meditate and how we work to improve the practice of mindfulness. It might be my ignorance, but it seemed “unmindful” to try to attain a state of uber-relaxed ‘pure mind.’ I don’t even know what that means.

Brad Warner's forthcoming book is up at Amazon, with a release date of Apr 28, 2007. Brad writes a bit about the release in a post titled "Where Do We Go When We Die?" in his blog Hardcore Zen.

Hill Street Blues: In “California is Pathetic, Part 2” The Brad of Hardcore Zen tells us why he is getting so few to show up for zazen in his Hill Street Center. Basically, it’s because Buddhist practice “is hard work” and “most people are … lazy and pathetic.” He tells us, though, that he is happy to get what pathetic turnout he gets rather than suffer from what he calls The ‘Frampton Comes Alive’ Effect which is when “a whole bunch of people [show up] who are just there because being there is the thing to do.” I note that Brad’s sentiments here seem to be in sharp contrast to the sentiment one gathers from the title of Brad’s forthcoming book [see graphic at right]. We may have to wait until the book is out to square this circle.

Up from the gutter and into the fast lane: Nagarjuna is in a slump; his bowling scores are way down and this after learning about some of the game's finer points. He is convinced that in order to get his game squared away he must get a boost of confidence – not only at the bowling center but in his life generally. He writes in Naked Reflections,
“[A]ct the way I wish to feel, and feel the way I wish to act.” In Star Trek, there is something called the “Rules of Acquisition” that act as the guiding principles of all self-respecting Ferengi in their daily conduct, aimed, as it is, at building wealth and power. I'm tempted to construct my own personal list of guiding rules or precepts with the maxim above at or near the top of that list.

Buddhism is very fortunate to have a stellar, hard-working guide at About.com in Anthony Flanagan. For quite some time the entries Anthony posts have been in blog format so I am happy to start appropriately recognizing his work as part of the buddhoblogosphere. Anthony’s latest post is about Rahula, the Buddha’s son. It is yet another expertly written essay of Anthony’s focusing on Buddhism basics in About Buddhism. Anthony's essays that are beyond or well beyond the basics are also expertly written. Svaha!

The latest issue of Holons [for Nov 06] – news from the Integral world [but decidedly NOT Frank Vissar’s Integral World] – includes reviews by C4 and Vincent Horn. Each mentions his work in his solo blog. C4 reviews the DVD release of the film Running Scared. C4 writes in his blog, ~C4Chaos, “Even Roger Ebert agrees with me :) So if you think you can handle it, check out the movie.” Vincent reviews Alan Wallace’s new book The Attention Revolution. Says Vince in Numinous Nonsense, delighted with the publishing credit, “Suweet. … Pretty cool because I also just recorded an interview with … Wallace for [the new group podcast blog] Buddhist Geeks.”

It takes a village: Jack [aka, Jeb] – well known to longstanding B’du readers for his defunct Wondering on the Way <q.v.> blog, which was the sterling Buddhist voice during the Katrina disaster – is building up Buddhist Village which acts as a community with an ezine at its hub. Check it out, AND latch on to the village feed.

Atheism Discussion

And finally, for today, Sean of Deep Surface and Bob of Dust are mainstays in a cross-blog discussion going on regarding atheism. In “Atheists and Development,” Sean writes that he agrees with famed atheist Sam Harris that “helping the faithful to understand reason is important for the survival of our species.” Stuart Davis in his stuartdavis blog had ripped into the idea, writing in an “Open Letter to Rational Pundits,” “We had better figure out how to see depth, experience altitudes of awareness, and embrace development, or those lower stations will render us undone.”

Dust’s Bob had a serious, mad, but funny, too, and “Cranky, mean-spirited reaction to Stuart Davis’s blog,” writing to Stu that he is “flat, flat, flat-out full of shit when you parrot Wilber’s smoke and mirrors ‘solution’ to the world’s problems.”

In a later, calmer post, Bob writes, “How did I change my mind about religious faith? Or if you prefer, How did I develop to a more inclusive worldview? The answer to both questions is the same in my case: I was exposed, over time, to series of thoughtful, rational, evidence-based perspectives that eventually made utterly transparent the silliness, ignorance, and self-limiting nature of religious dogma. And until integral or developmental theorists can demonstrate a more effective approach to this problem, or any other for that matter, I will have to go with what’s worked for me.”

C4 of the blog ~C4Chaos, in a thoughtful comment to Bob’s words suggests “gather[ing] people in different religions and faith who already are at the world-centric stage of development and do the rational dialogue with them instead of attempt[ing] to dialogue among the masses.”